Even though it’s late in the lifecycle of MLB The Show 23, there are still things for Diamond Dynasty players to do. The MLB The Show 23 Finders Keepers Collection has allowed players to unlock new rewards, including a 99 OVR Kyle Seager and 99 OVR Brian Roberts. But how exactly can MLB The Show 23 players unlock the Seager and future rewards? Let’s take a look.
Related: MLB The Show 23: Budget Beasts cards in Diamond Dynasty
How to complete Finders Keepers Collection in MLB The Show 23
To complete the Finders Keepers Collection in MLB The Show 23, one must obtain several specific 2023 Finest and Retro Finest cards. Here’s a look at each card that needs to be obtained:
| Card | How to obtain |
|---|---|
| 99 OVR 2023 Finest Francisco Alvarez | MLB The Show 23 2023 Finest Choice Pack/Marketplace |
| 99 OVR 2023 Finest George Kirby | MLB The Show 23 2023 Finest Choice Pack/Marketplace |
| 99 OVR 2023 Finest Gunnar Henderson | Marketplace |
| 99 OVR 2023 Finest Evan Phillips | MLB The Show 23 2023 Finest Choice Pack/Marketplace |
| 99 OVR 2023 Finest Devin Williams | MLB The Show 23 2023 Finest Choice Pack/Marketplace |
| 99 OVR 2023 Finest Jake Burger | MLB The Show 23 2023 Finest Choice Pack/Marketplace |
| 99 OVR 2023 Finest Sean Murphy | Marketplace |
| 99 OVR Retro Finest Wade Boggs | Marketplace |
| 99 OVR Retro Finest Bill Mazeroski | Marketplace |
| 99 OVR Retro Finest Lee Smith | Marketplace |
| 99 OVR 2023 Finest Nolan Arenado | Marketplace |
| 99 OVR 2023 Finest Aroldis Chapman | Marketplace |
| 99 OVR 2023 Finest Paul Goldschmidt | Marketplace |
| 99 OVR 2023 Finest Luis Arraez | Marketplace |
| 99 OVR 2023 Finest Robert Stephenson | Marketplace |
| 99 OVR Retro Finest Keith Hernandez | Finders Keepers Pack 4/Marketplace |
| 99 OVR Retro Finest Tim Salmon | Finders Keepers Pack 5/Marketplace |
| 99 OVR Retro Finest Lefty Grove | Finders Keepers Pack 6/Marketplace |
| 99 OVR Retro Finest Steve Finley | Finders Keepers Pack 7/Marketplace |
Those who can claim at least seven cards in this Collection will receive a 99 OVR Retro Finest of Kyle Seager.
MLB The Show 23 players that can collect 15 will receive a 99 OVR Retro Finest Brian Roberts.
Lastly, all 19 cards will earn MLB The Show 23 players a 99 OVR Retro Finest Steve Finley.
The third and final Finders Keepers Collection player reward was made available on January 19, 2024.