Over the past few years, Sony has done something to celebrate Halloween in Diamond Dynasty. For MLB The Show 26, the Spooky Program launched on October 26, part of a week-long build-up towards new 99 OVR cards. It ended on October 30, when Sony released a 99 OVR Spooky Jorge Polanco to cap off the program.
Spooky Program reward path
Here’s a look at the Spooky Program in MLB The Show 26:
- 5 Points: Spider Web Banner
- 10 Points: Deluxe pack
- 15 Points: Mummy Icon
- 20 Points: 99 OVR Spooky J.R. Richard & 4,000 XP
- 25 Points: Werewolf Icon
- 30 Points: Deluxe pack
- 35 Points: MLB Draft Deluxe Pack
- 40 Points: 99 OVR Spooky Mark McGwire & 4,000 XP
- 45 Points: Werewolf Stadium Sound
- 50 Points: Deluxe pack
- 55 Points: Premier pack
- 60 Points: 99 OVR Spooky Sammy Sosa & 4,000 XP
- 65 Points: Goat Stadium Sound
- 70 Points: Deluxe pack
- 75 Points: Vault Choice Pack
- 80 Points: 99 OVR Spooky Andrew Miller & 4,000 XP
- 85 Points: Halloween Bat Skin
- 90 Points: Deluxe pack
- 95 Points: Headliners Choice Player Pack
- 100 Points: 99 OVR Spooky Jorge Polanco & 4,000 XP
This program will work a bit differently compared to MLB The Show 25. For one, this one won’t be dragged out for a full month, only one week. Second, fewer player items.
On October 26, the first in-program card reward, 99 OVR JR Richard, was released. Mark McGwire was released on the 27th, and Sosa came on the 28th. Andrew Miller’s 99 OVR was added on the 29th. The last one, 99 OVR Jorge Polanco, was added on the 30th:
J.R. Richard

Mark McGwire

Sammy Sosa

Andrew Miller

Jorge Polanco

How to make progress
Here are the tasks:
- Complete Spooky Conquest (20 pts.)
- Collect 99 OVR Spooky Clay Buchholz (20 pts.)
- Collect 99 OVR Spooky Kerry Wood or Bo Bichette (20 pts.)
- Complete five Moments (20 pts. – 4 pts. each)
- PXP Missions:
- Tally 1,026 PXP with Live Series players (4 pts.)
- Tally 1,027 PXP with Moonshot Series players (4 pts.)
- Tally 1,028 PXP with Topps Now Series players (4 pts.)
- Tally 1,029 PXP with primary second basemen (4 pts.)
- Tally 1,030 PXP with switch-hitters (4 pts.)
The 99 OVR Clay Buchholz is obtainable in the Spooky Mini Seasons, along with Gary Sheffield, Brian Roberts, & Carlos Santana. To unlock Buchholz, tally 1,313 PXP in the Spooky Mini Seasons.

On October 28, Sony added a Spooky Diamond Quest with Bo Bichette & Kerry Wood as earnable rewards. Unlike most Diamond Quest rewards, neither Bichette nor Wood are sellable. That means to make progress in the program, you have to get one of the two the hard way.
Do the Conquest and unlock a 99 OVR Willie Mays in the process.

More cards and tasks will be added throughout Halloween week.
Check out more of our gaming coverage, including the 2026 Postseason content.

