Tim Hill has been a large part of the Yankees’ bullpen for much of the last three seasons. Hill is set for a fourth season in New York, as the Yankees have reportedly agreed to bring the sinkerballer back for a fourth season.
A Look at Hill
The Yankees had success with Tim Hill in 2024, which prompted the club to give the veteran left-hander a one-year deal in 2025. That contract also came with a 2026 club option that was exercised in November 2025. Hill had a fantastic 2025 campaign, as far as ERA was concerned. But that changed a bit in 2026.
In what was another workhorse season for Hill, the left-hander pitched in 67 contests and struck out just 25, not unbelievable given his tendencies. However, Hill allowed 12 home runs last year, making sense of the 4.60 ERA. His 1.9 HR/9 was among the 15 highest for relievers this season (min. 35 GP).
It’s almost a bizarre thing to write, especially when taking into account how many groundballs Hill conceded in 2026. His 68.9% cumulative GB% (which takes into account groundballs and bunts considered one) was easily the highest in the league. Tyler Rogers, a fellow submarine pitcher, was second behind Hill.

Out of the 12 home runs he allowed, eight were off that sinker he has, a pitch that’s carried him for his career. The other four were off the fastball (2) and slider (2). However, when looking at the year-by-year Barrel%, Hill conceded roughly the same amount of well-hit contact off that two-seamer. So, you figure that the averages will adjust over the long run (or hope anyway).

Hill has never been a hard thrower. Instead, he relies on his funky delivery for deception, which he has worked for much of his MLB career.
Per ESPN, the Yankees brought back Tim Hill on a one-year deal worth $2.25MM. It also came with a club option for 2028 that is worth $2.5MM.
Analysis
The Yankees started the process of replenishing the bullpen by bringing back Hill,
New York entered the offseason with just one true left-handed reliever on the 40-man roster, that being Brent Headrick. Both Hill and Ryan Yarbrough went to free agency, part of what was a lengthy list of bullpen arms to walk.
While this move obviously doesn’t solve the closer problem that the Yankees still face, it does give Aaron Boone another matchup left-hander that he sorely needed for 2027 (and potentially 2028, should the Yankees exercise that club option).
And for those wondering why the Yankees would go back to the well again with Hill after a down 2026, it’s illustrated pretty well in the previous section. Hill is an outlier pitcher; he generates groundballs at a rate that no other hurler does in today’s game. And by and large, it works.
Also, he’s a very unique look out of the bullpen.
Check out more of our MLB coverage.

