2024 MLB Bet Picks for May 23: Best props, odds, more

Just eight games are scheduled for May 23 in Major League Baseball. Among those games include the end of the four-game series between the Mariners and Yankees, and the start of a pivotal series for both the Blue Jays and Tigers. So, what looks good on the betting front? Here’s our lone MLB bet for May 23, 2024.

Our best bets for May 23

Here’s a look at our best MLB bets, or bet, given the few number of games, for May 23 (odds via BetMGM New York Sportsbook):

  • Mariners/Yankees under eight runs (-110)

The Yankees and Mariners have scored over eight combined runs in each of the first three games in their four-game series. Nine runs were scored on May 20 in a game where Clay Holmes blew the save opportunity for the Yankees and that stretch continued on the 22nd when Aaron Judge and Juan Soto went deep for three combined home runs.

The series will conclude on the 23rd with a pair of hot pitchers on the mound. Luis Gil struck out 14 batters last weekend against the White Sox, while Luis Castillo has conceded two or fewer runs in each of his last five starts.

It’s an early game that’ll start at 12:35 PM ET/9:35 AM PT.

We won’t go with multiple MLB bets for May 23, though, due to the light schedule.

Look at May 21’s picks

For reference, these were our picks for May 21. We did not have picks on May 22:

2024 Total Record: 39-33

Chris Studley contributed to this report.


The individual(s) who contribute to this 2024 MLB article may use strategies not listed here. Please bet responsibly.

If you or someone you know has a gambling problem, please call the New York Problem Gambling Helpline: 1-877-8-HOPENY (467369) or Text HOPENY (467369). Individuals who want to enroll can to the New York Self-Exclusion Program.