It was a tough season for the Mets, one that started with high expectations after a busy summer. After a roster blowup, the Mets came out flat early on and didn’t recover until after Carlos Mendoza was relieved of his duties. Things under Andy Green, now the permanent manager, improved. But in the end, the Mets went 74-88 in 2026.

The Offense

StatNumberRank
Runs Scored130820th
Home Runs204t-7th
OPS.70623rd
Whiff%25.215th
Hard Hit%41.72nd

The Pitching

StatNumberRank
Starters’ ERA4.4723rd
Relievers’ ERA3.7610th
Strikeouts1450t-6th
Whiff%24.915th
Chase%30.812th

The Good

Even though the Mets didn’t meet expectations in 2026, perhaps the best news from last season was the fact that the youngsters found their groove as regulars.

Outfielder Carson Benge made the big-league club out of camp, less than two years after the team made him a first-round pick in 2024. Benge hit some rough patches offensively in the early goings-on, ultimately making a big adjustment at the plate.

At the start of the year, Benge (as you can see below) had a very open stance at the plate.

Now, that worked in the Minors. But as the season went along, Benge fine-tuned his stance, keeping the timing mechanism but becoming more square at the plate. Fewer moving parts at the plate, and Benge didn’t compromise anything in his approach. He stayed relatively short and on plane.

Over his last 50 games, Benge slashed .315/.381/.497 with nine home runs and 17 extra-base hits. The soon-to-be sophomore outfielder had himself a 20-home-run season and became one of baseball’s most feared arms in right field, as well.

It was also an adjustment period for Nolan McLean. McLean took up the mantle as staff ace during his rookie season, striking out 194 over 179.2 IP. What hurt McLean for some time was his inability to execute with the sweeper. But once he increased the usage of that pitcher from July onward, McLean’s performance soared.

McLean posted a strong 2.45 ERA over his last 14 starts in 2026.

The Mets also saw Zac Thornton and Christian Scott establish themselves as reliable rotation arms. Thornton was a tough at-bat for hitters, even though the left-hander doesn’t have plus velocity. Good angling, good stuff, and a sub-4.00 ERA for the rookie from July 1 onward. Not too bad for a pitcher who was promoted in late May with limited Triple-A experience.

As for Scott, he dodged a rough first start with the Mets and was masterful for much of 2026. The right-hander struck out 134 batters in 110 innings, and ranked 53rd among starting pitchers (min. 100 IP) in opponents’ wOBA (.302).

Those three made up the core of the Mets’ rotation for much of 2026.

Moving along, the Mets had, perhaps, one of baseball’s most underrated bullpens. Brooks Raley and A.J. Minter were both sublime before being moved at the deadline. Luke Weaver, when traded to the Pirates, had a stellar 1.84 ERA and was, arguably, the best reliever the Mets had all season.

Devin Williams, the team’s closer, missed a lot of bats, just like he did in Milwaukee.

After the deadline, the bullpen continued to be effective. New York struck gold with Nate Lavender, who has a tough fastball to hit. So does Jefry Yan, who regularly flirted with or touched triple digits. Kodai Senga pitched well out of the bullpen, and a returning Dedniel Nunez was effective, too.

Back to the offense, there were highlights aside from Benge. Fellow rookie A.J. Ewing hit 11 home runs, stole 25 bases, and covered a lot of ground in center field. His fellow outfielder, Juan Soto, hit 27 home runs in 111 games, a pace that would have easily gotten him to 30 had he not been hurt in parts of 2026.

Jared Young, a journeyman 1B/OF, hit nine home runs and 29 extra-base hits. Sure, Young was a platoon bat — but a valuable one at that.

The Bad

Heading into the season, the Mets had significant expectations. Instead, the club won 74 games. And while the club played above .500 baseball, believe it or not, after the trade deadline, what happened beforehand sunk the team.

Starting with the offense, Francisco Lindor didn’t have a great season. In an injury-shortened campaign, Lindor slashed .225/.309/.423 with 21 home runs and 37 extra-base hits. However, 11 of those home runs came between August 1 and September 13.

Injuries were a problem for that offense. Mark Vientos missed time, as did Luis Robert Jr. Francisco Alvarez missed several weeks with a meniscus tear. Those injuries didn’t stop with the hitters, either, as Clay Holmes missed more than two months after he took a liner off the leg in mid-May.

It wound up being Holmes’ last act as a Met. New York traded him to the Cubs, along with Tyrone Taylor, at the deadline for prospect Jefferson Rojas.

Then, there were the offseason acquisitions that didn’t pan out as hoped.

Freddy Peralta was acquired last offseason from the Brewers after a terrific tenure for him in Milwaukee. But with free agency looming, the Brewers opted to acquire futures for their once-former ace.

But in 2026, the metrics were off on his stuff. Fewer swing-and-misses on his fastball and sweeper, and far too many instances in which he couldn’t go deep into outings. Ultimately, a new home & approach in Tampa Bay helped Peralta after the Mets traded him in August.

Marcus Semien was brought in to shake up the club and shore up second base defensively. But in 2026, his offense lagged, and so did the glove. Semien had a -9 Outs Above Average, one of the worst in the league.

Bo Bichette was added in mid-January, after the club missed out on Kyle Tucker. Bichette was given a massive three-year, $126MM deal, positioning him as one of baseball’s highest-paid players.

Now, that kind of contract came with lofty expectations, expectations that were going to be near-impossible to match. He hit well after April but, overall, slashed .260/.312/.390.

Early Projected Lineup for 2027

With Bo Bichette locked in for 2027, that roughly squares away the infield. The big wild card is first base. Will Jared Young be that guy? Can Mark Vientos work his way back after two unspectacular years? Or, will the Mets land a big fish to play, like Teruaki Sato?

As for the rotation, all eyes, as of mid-November, were on the club and whether or not Tarik Skubal would sign with the team. With three pitchers set to make a tick above the league minimum in that rotation, plus more help on the way, the Mets have some financial flexibility to play with.

Check out more of our MLB coverage.


Discover more from New Baseball Media

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Owned & operated by Big Boys Media LLC