Despite some brief hiccups down the stretch, the 2026 campaign was a much better one for Dustin May. The former Brewer turned that season into a three-year deal with the White Sox, a team that needed some pitching help.

A Look at May

When the Cardinals signed pitcher Dustin May in December of last year, it was a chance at redemption for the right-hander after a difficult 2025 campaign. May was hit hard in Boston after the Red Sox acquired him from the Dodgers that summer, in a stint that didn’t last too long thanks to injury.

Well, things turned around quite nicely for May in St. Louis.

May struck out 109 batters over 106 frames for St. Louis in 2026, a stint that ended when the club traded him to Milwaukee at the deadline. He pitched well in spurts out of the rotation for Milwaukee, although the home run ball hurt him in the regular season. In 10 regular-season outings, May allowed seven home runs with the Brewers.

He ultimately wound up as a multi-inning reliever for the Brewers during their World Series title run.

Overall, May allowed only 14 home runs and struck out 144 over 145.2 IP. His .317 opponents’ wOBA ranked 83rd among the 140 starters who accumulated at least 100 innings last year.

The 2026 season saw May unleash a new weapon: a curveball that wound up being a nice tool, amidst a noticeable shakeup in his pitch mix. More four-seam fastballs, more cutters, and far fewer sinkers and sweepers.

Now, that doesn’t mean the pitches that he lowered the usage on didn’t have value. On the contrary, the tick up in usage of his cutter and fastball actually didn’t help quite a bit, especially when trying to set up his sweeper.

Out of the 54 total whiffs induced off the sweeper, 34 were preceded by a four-seamer or cutter; 19 were preceded by a cutter. Sure, his sweeper still didn’t have a big overall uptick in Whiff%. Last season, it was a hair above 26%. In 2026, it was slightly above 27%. Nonetheless, something to consider.

Additionally, no hitter recorded a barrel on May’s curveball. That pitch is a tough one for hitters. It’s hard (a mid-80s pitch), shortened-up, and yet can induce a lot of groundballs because of that late action.

Per multiple reports, the White Sox will bring in Dustin May on a three-year deal worth $52.5MM.

Analysis

The White Sox came into the winter with a need for pitching, both bullpen help and extra arms for the rotation.

Chicago has a nice setup for the future, as Sean Burke and Davis Martin both look like keepers, even though the latter ticked down as the season went on. Noah Schultz didn’t have a great rookie season but is a young arm to watch. And if Hagen Smith can hold up, he could be a special arm despite the high walk totals.

Still, the White Sox needed a reliable, veteran arm. May provides that. He comes with years of experience, including pitching for a couple of World Series teams in 2020 and 2026, plus has a deep pitch mix that can get both lefties and righties.

Check out more of our MLB coverage.


Discover more from New Baseball Media

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Owned & operated by Big Boys Media LLC