2024 MLB Bet Picks for May 9: Best props, odds, more

Just seven games are scheduled for May 9, highlighted by a late-afternoon tilt in The Bronx between the Astros and Yankees and an NL Central matchup between the Cardinals and Brewers. Because of the light schedule, there won’t be as many betting options compared to the past three days. Nonetheless, we have our picks, or rather pick. Here are our best MLB bets for May 9, 2024.

Our best bets for May 9

Here’s a look at our best MLB bets, or in this case, bet for May 9 (odds via BetMGM New York Sportsbook):

  • Giants/Rockies over 5 runs in first five innings (-105)

It’s a light day of action, so why not go for a pick involving two teams at hitter-friendly Coors Field? The Rockies lost the first game of this series 5-0 thanks to a brilliant performance from Kyle Harrison, and these two teams went after it on May 8. Ten runs were scored during the first five innings on the 8th, as Michael Conforto went deep on Peter Lambert, who gave up seven runs over three innings.

It’s an interesting pitching matchup on May 9, as Keaton Winn will look to shake off a poor performance on May 4 when he didn’t make it through one inning against the Phillies. Winn doesn’t miss many bats, as he’s a pitch-to-contact arm who leans heavily on his splitter and sinker.

Winn will face Cal Quantrill, a fellow sinkerballer who’s pitched better on the road (.646 OPS) this season than at Coors Field (.785).

Look at May 8’s picks

For reference, these were our picks for May 8:

  • Sonny Gray over 5.5 strikeouts (-120) (PPD)
  • Padres/Cubs under 8.5 runs (-130)

2024 Total Record: 33-24

Chris Studley contributed to this report.


The individual(s) who contribute to this 2024 MLB article may use strategies not listed here. Please bet responsibly.

If you or someone you know has a gambling problem, please call the New York Problem Gambling Helpline: 1-877-8-HOPENY (467369) or Text HOPENY (467369). In