For the third consecutive year in 2026, the Yankees earned a playoff spot and won at least one playoff round. However, just like in 2025, when New York fell to Toronto, the Yankees couldn’t get past another AL East rival, the Rays, in the ALDS. It ended what was a fantastic year, especially for the stars who kept the Yankees’ season from veering off course. But it was one of the years where you can only ask “what if?”
The Offense
| Stat | Number | Rank |
|---|---|---|
| Runs Scored | 739 | t-9th |
| Home Runs | 223 | 2nd |
| OPS | .720 | t-11th |
| Whiff% | 27.1 | 26th |
| Hard Hit% | 41.6 | 3rd |
The Pitching
| Stat | Number | Rank |
|---|---|---|
| Starters’ ERA | 3.30 | 1st |
| Relievers’ ERA | 3.13 | 2nd |
| Strikeouts | 1450 | t-6th |
| Whiff% | 26.4 | 6th |
| Chase% | 30.3 | 15th |
The Good
The Yankees didn’t have Aaron Judge available for much of 2026, leaving Ben Rice to pick up the slack.
Rice had 28 home runs entering the All-Star break, an impressive total given that he lost the protection of Judge. But 2026 proved just how dangerous a hitter Rice is, even without that protection. He finished 2026 with 69 extra-base hits, 41 home runs, and a .384 wOBA that ranked as the fifth-best in the Majors (min. 375 PA).
He also had the third-highest SLG (.534), behind only the two MVPs from 2026.
The vast majority of the Yankees’ lineup that went into the playoffs had at least 10 home runs. It was a list that included Cody Bellinger, Jose Caballero, Austin Wells, Paul Goldschmidt, Aaron Judge, plus rookie Spencer Jones.
While the club didn’t have the whole lineup ticking at once, it helped that there were moments where certain players helped carry the load at certain times.
Goldschmidt, for example, had a strong six weeks before the All-Star break. From June 1 through July 12, Goldschmidt hit nine home runs and was killing left-handed pitching.
From August 4 through the end of the year, the Yankees had seven hitters hit at least six home runs: Trent Grisham, George Lombard Jr., newcomer Luis Garcia Jr., Rice, Bellinger, Wells, and Jones.
Lombard Jr. had his moments in his first taste of MLB action but is a keeper. Jones, meanwhile, had his problems with swing-and-miss and fastballs, as expected. But he connected when it mattered, showing that the tools can translate to big-league success.

As for the pitching staff, you can’t start the conversation without the reigning Cy Young Award winner: Cam Schlittler.
Schlittler, in his true breakout season, bombarded opposing hitters with fastball after fastball and dared them to hit. More often than not, those hitters couldn’t. And while he was fastball-heavy, Schlittler also knew when to shake things up, working a hard fastball that missed a lot of bats.

He wound up being the ace in a season where Max Fried had a great, albeit injury-shortened season. Fried had the lowest HR/9 (.3) in the Majors, part of a campaign where he also finished top five in opponents’ wOBA (.245) and posted a stellar 2.80 ERA.
Gerrit Cole, over a year removed from UCL reconstruction surgery, struck out 131 over 127 innings and limited the walks.
The Yankees’ bullpen was also formidable, as David Bednar a bullpen that received breakout years from Brent Headrick and Paul Blackburn. Blackburn put out fire after fire, while Headrick was a master at getting opposing hitters to whiff and expand out of the zone.

Two under-the-radar moves wound up paying significant dividends for the Yankees.
The Bad
While statistically, nothing seemed amiss on the stat sheet for the Yankees during the regular season, there were issues that need to be pointed.
Some of those issues were uncontrollable. Aaron Judge hit 18 home runs in 2026 but only played 66 games, thanks to numerous injuries. Judge missed three months with a rib injury, coming back in September without a rehab assignment. But shortly thereafter, Judge went down with a calf strain and missed the rest of the regular season, plus the club’s two playoff rounds.
Giancarlo Stanton, like Judge, missed most of 2026. Stanton only accumulated 96 plate appearances in the regular season. A noted playoff performer, Stanton was activated in the playoffs but was only used as a pinch-hitter.
Austin Wells hit just .186 for the Yankees and posted one of the lowest wOBA figures (.281) in the league.
The other big problem for the Yankees in 2026 was defense. Sloppy defense doomed the Yankees in the 2026 ALDS, as the club made four errors — a fifth one was wiped off — in Game 2 of the series against the Rays.
A lot went wrong in that series. Ben Rice was the only consistent hitter for the Yanks, and Tampa Bay had great at-bats. But that night was a watershed moment for the Yankees, and it only continued an ongoing conversation about fundamentals in The Bronx.
For those who subscribe to the analytics, the two best defenders last season were, oddly enough, Jazz Chisholm Jr. and Anthony Volpe. Both are rangy defenders, although they’ve made their fair share of mistakes over the years.
Speaking of Chisholm Jr., he did not have the ideal offensive season in his walk year. While he did steal 41 bases, Chisholm Jr. slashed .231/.312/.399 (.711 OPS) in 2026. That came one year after the second baseman put up a 30-30 campaign.
Early Projected Lineup for 2027
- C: Austin Wells
- 1B: Ben Rice
- 2B: Luis Garcia Jr./Anthony Volpe
- 3B: Jose Caballero
- SS: George Lombard Jr.
- OF: Cody Bellinger (LF), Spencer Jones (CF), Aaron Judge (RF)
- DH: Heliot Ramos/Luis Garcia Jr./Giancarlo Stanton
- SP: Cam Schlittler, Max Fried, Gerrit Cole, Carlos Rodon, Ryan Weathers, Will Warren
- RP: David Bednar, Jonathan Loaisiga, Brent Headrick, Tim Hill, Angel Chivilli, Bradley Hanner, Clarke Schmidt
The Yankees have already made an effort to replenish the bullpen, re-signing Tim Hill and Jonathan Loaisiga. David Bednar took his qualifying offer, bringing back the club’s closer from 2026.
There are wild cards, including how the Yankees will handle Luis Garcia Jr. Without Jazz Chisholm Jr., Garcia Jr. could be playing all over the right side of that infield, plus slot in as a DH.
Check out more of our MLB coverage.

