On October 6, San Diego Studio released the final Monthly Awards program in MLB The Show 23. The primary reward is a 99 OVR Lightning of Juan Soto, but several other 99 OVRs can be had in this program. Here’s how to complete the MLB The Show 23 September Monthly Awards Program.
Related: MLB The Show 23: Budget Beasts cards in Diamond Dynasty
MLB The Show 23 September Monthly Awards Reward Path
The reward path looks quite similar to the ones we saw for June, July, and August. Here’s a look at the reward path for the MLB The Show 23 September Monthly Awards Program:
- 2 Star Points – 97 OVR September MA Captain Jack Flaherty
- 4 Star Points – 97 OVR September MA Captain J.D. Martinez
- 6 Star Points – 95 OVR September MA Hoby Milner and 3,000 XP
- 8 Star Points – 96 OVR September MA Andy Ibanez
- 10 Star Points – 96 OVR September MA Nelson Velasquez
- 15 Star Points – 96 OVR September MA Shelby Miller
- 20 Star Points – 96 OVR September MA Reynaldo Lopez and 1,000 Stubs
- 25 Star Points – 97 OVR September MA Logan O’Hoppe
- 30 Star Points – 97 OVR September MA Willi Castro and 3,000 XP
- 35 Star Points – 97 OVR September MA Gunnar Henderson
- 40 Star Points – 97 OVR September MA Reese Olson
- 45 Star Points – 97 OVR September MA Sean Manaea and 1,000 Stubs
- 50 Star Points – 97 OVR September MA Jameson Taillon
- 55 Star Points – 97 OVR September MA Jake Diekman
- 60 Star Points – 98 OVR September MA Will Vest
- 65 Star Points – 98 OVR September MA Nick Pivetta and 3,000 XP
- 70 Star Points – 98 OVR September MA Christian Encarnacion-Strand and 1,000 Stubs
- 75 Star Points – 98 OVR September MA TJ Friedl
- 80 Star Points – 99 OVR September MA Michael King
- 85 Star Points – 99 OVR September MA Seiya Suzuki
- 90 Star Points – 99 OVR September MA James McArthur
- 95 Star Points – Bat Skin and 1,000 Stubs
- 100 Star Points – 99 OVR September MA Lighting Juan Soto and 3,000 XP
Here’s a look at the stats on the 99 OVR Juan Soto.
Juan Soto

All cards from this Program belong to Set 4.
How to Make Progress in September Monthly Awards Program
Here’s a look at all the ways that players can make progress in the September Monthly Awards Program:
- Collect POTM Tyler Naquin, Fernando Tatis Jr. and Tyler O’Neill (6, 25, & 30 pts. respectively) (OPTIONAL)
- Collect six 97 OVR and one 99 OVR September Topps Now cards (10 pts.) (OPTIONAL)
- Collect Monthly Awards Ty France, Cole Irvin, Andres Munoz, Bryan Reynolds, Ramon Urias, and Carlos Pena (all 2 pts. each except Pena, which is 15 pts.) (OPTIONAL)
- Complete Set 3 player exchange (10 pts.) (OPTIONAL)
- Complete 22 Moments (44 pts. – 2 pts. each)
- Single-Player Missions:
- Tally 50 total bases with September Monthly Awards cards (including Captain J.D. Martinez) (Play vs. CPU, Mini Seasons, and Conquest) (5 pts.)
- Tally 27 innings with September Monthly Awards cards (including Captain Jack Flaherty) (Play vs. CPU, Mini Seasons, and Conquest) (5 pts.)
- Tally 30 strikeouts with September Monthly Awards cards (including Captain Jack Flaherty) (Play vs. CPU, Mini Seasons, and Conquest) (5 pts.)
- Tally 15 extra-base hits with September Monthly Awards cards (including Captain J.D. Martinez) (Play vs. CPU, Mini Seasons, and Conquest) (5 pts.)
- Online Missions:
- Tally eight extra-base hits with September Monthly Awards cards (including Captain J.D. Martinez) (1v1 Ranked, Battle Royale, and Events) (5 pts.)
- Tally 18 innings with September Monthly Awards cards (including Captain Jack Flaherty) (1v1 Ranked, Battle Royale, and Events) (5 pts.)
- Tally 15 strikeouts with September Monthly Awards cards (including Captain Jack Flaherty) (1v1 Ranked, Battle Royale, and Events) (5 pts.)
- Tally eight extra-base hits with September Monthly Awards cards (including Captain J.D. Martinez) (1v1 Ranked, Battle Royale, and Events) (5 pts.)
- PXP Missions:
- Tally 5,000 PXP with September Monthly Awards cards (1v1 Ranked, Battle Royale, Events, Play vs. CPU, Mini Seasons, and Conquest) (15 pts.)
- Tally 1,000 PXP with September Monthly Awards Hitters (1v1 Ranked, Battle Royale, Events, Play vs. CPU, Mini Seasons, and Conquest) (5 pts.)
- Tally 1,000 PXP with September Monthly Awards Pitchers (1v1 Ranked, Battle Royale, Events, Play vs. CPU, Mini Seasons, and Conquest) (5 pts.)
- Tally 200 PXP with Captain J.D. Martinez (1v1 Ranked, Battle Royale, Events, Play vs. CPU, Mini Seasons, and Conquest) (5 pts.)
- Tally 500 PXP with Captain Jack Flaherty (1v1 Ranked, Battle Royale, Events, Play vs. CPU, Mini Seasons, and Conquest) (5 pts.)
A couple of notes on the tasks for the September Monthly Awards Guide. One, the Monthly Awards Flashbacks of France, Irvin, Munoz, Reynolds, Urias, and Pena can be obtained via the Monthly Awards and Topps Now Mini Seasons.
Second, the Event for the Naquin, Tatis Jr. and O’Neill cards cards will be active through October 13. The requirements are Captain, Live Series, Topps Now, and Monthly Awards cards..
Third, the Topps Now cards are optional for this program. However, those who have the six 97 OVR cards from the September Topps Now Program, plus the 99 OVR Topps Now Wainwright will have an easier time completing this one.

